Find a gluten-free recipe!
gluten-free. dairy-free. re-imagined for everyday life.

Chiara’s Gluten-Free Vanilla Birthday Cake with Strawberry Frosting

One of the goals I had when I was developing my gluten-free flour blend is that it would be 100% interchangeable with gluten-full all-purpose flour. I′m happy to report that it was a success and works beautifully  in this cake recipe. As my friend Tracey said before she directed me to her cake recipe, you will never make any other vanilla cake recipe again. Needless to say, she was right!

Make sure your butter is softened well before starting this recipe. It makes all the difference in the world in the cake′s texture. Also, while the batter is quite thick, it yields such a wonderfully airy cake. And, because the frosting is made with real (fresh or frozen) strawberries and no artificial food coloring, it can start to separate slightly. Just beat in more sifted confectioners’ sugar, if necessary, to stabilize the acidity in the strawberries. Depending on how much frosting you like between your cake layers and whether you’ll be making a two- or four-layer cake, you may want to double the quantity of frosting.

(Visited 176 times, 3 visits today)
Get my weekly newsletter
for exclusive recipes, tips
and giveaways...It's FREE!

Makes: One 9-inch, 4-layer cake

For the vanilla cake:
3½ cups Silvana’s Kitchen Gluten-Free All-Purpose Flour
1 tablespoon baking powder
¾ teaspoon baking soda
1 teaspoon salt
2 sticks (1 cup) unsalted butter, softened
2 cups sugar
4 large eggs, at room temperature
1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract
2 cups sour cream

For the strawberry frosting:
1 cup all-vegetable shortening, at room temperature
3 cups confectioners′ sugar, sifted
½ cup strawberry puree
1/4 teaspoon salt
Butterfly sprinkles, for topping

The cake is adapted from my friend Tracey Seaman; here′s the original recipe with great baking and decorating tips. The frosting is based off a recipe in my book, Cooking for Isaiah.

1. Preheat the oven to 350 °F. Butter 2 (9- by 2-inch) round cake pans and line bottoms of each with rounds of wax or parchment paper. Butter paper and dust pans with flour, knocking out excess.
2. Make the cake: Sift together flour, baking powder, baking soda and salt.
3. Beat together butter and sugar in a large bowl with an electric mixer until light and fluffy. Add eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition, then beat in the vanilla. Add half of the flour mixture and mix at low speed until just blended. Add the sour cream, mixing until just combined, then add the remaining flour mixture, mixing at low speed until the batter is smooth.
4. Divide the batter between pans, smoothing the tops. Bake in the middle of the oven until the cake is springy to the touch and a tester comes out clean, 30 to 40 minutes. Cool in pans on racks for about 10 minutes, then invert onto racks, remove paper, and cool completely.
5. Trim tops of cooled cake layers with a long serrated knife if necessary to make flat and level. Halve each layer horizontally with serrated knife to make a total of 4 layers.
6. Make the frosting: In a large bowl and using a handheld electric mixer, beat together the shortening, confectioners′ sugar, strawberry puree and salt on medium-high speed until fluffy.
7. Put 1 cake layer on a cake plate and spread with ¾ cup frosting. Layer the remaining cake layers using ¾ cup frosting between each layer. Frost the top and sides of cake with the remaining frosting. Top with sprinkles.

Halloween Chocolate-Peanut Butter Fudge Crunch
Mini Mac-and-Cheese Cakes with Corn Chex Crust

19 Comments: Chiara’s Gluten-Free Vanilla Birthday Cake with Strawberry Frosting

Jacie Wiggs Said:

Your daughter is so cute with her curly whirly hair! Cannot wait to try this Silvana…the sour cream addition to the cake sounds yummo! Loved your Zucchini bread…still loving it actually! Too much…;)

Nolamom Said:

I’ve just been advised to put my 6 yr old on a GFCF diet and luckily stumbled on your book, which making me feel a LITTLE less panicked. This cake looks delicious. Any suggestions for substituting a casein-free ingredient for the sour cream? Thanks!

Renie Said:

Although I have not tried this recipe, I have successfully substituted plain soy yogurt for sour cream in other recipes. Our Kroger store also stocks a DF/CF sour cream, the brand is Toufutti, I believe. My daughter likes this on baked potatoes and mexican food.

Jean Said:

Is there a good substitute for the sour cream? I am searching for a gluten free/dairy free yellow cupcake.

Tara Said:

I made this cake (but bought frosting) for my 3 year old son’s birthday a few weeks back. I am the only GF/DF person in the house and none of the guests were, either. No one could believe it was GF and DF – every adult guest asked for the recipe! It was truly delicious and I will be making it again next week for my mom’s birthday.

Jean, I used a DF sour cream called Sour Supreme, but you could use Tofutti sour cream as well.

Nicole Said:

I am looking to make a GF/DF cake for my son’s 1st birthday and this looks really good. Can I leave the strawberry puree out and still have the icing turn out okay? Also, can I substitute shortening for the 2 sticks of butter in the cake recipe? Thanks!

Silvana Said:

Hi Nicole!

You’ll need to substitute the puree with something else. Any ideas? You could just use rice milk, but I would add slowly until you get the right texture.

Also, the shortening substitute should work although I have NOT tested it with that. Please let me know how the birthday cake turns out—and a big happy birthday to your son!

Geraldine Said:

This cake looks lovely. What can I use as a substitution for the sugar?

Michelle Said:

I would use coconut-milk based from SO Delicious yogurt (or try rice or soy-based yogurts if you want)for the sour cream.

Tofutti also makes a soy-based sour cream that is good if soy can be used.

Geraldine Said:

Thank you Michelle. Both my son’s are gluten, wheat and dairy intolerant and Im trying to also cut out the sugar and yeast out of their diets. I use honey for small amounts of sugar but in this case cannot replace it with that. Will try.

Nicole Said:

Thank you so much for the ideas Silvana! He LOVES peaches from our Farmer’s Market, so I may try a peach puree in the icing for his smash cake and then just the rice milk for everyone else’s. His birthday is at the end of August, so I will probably test it beforehand. I will let you know how it all turns out!

Jane Said:

Wow, I made this today for my son’s birthday (with vanilla frosting; pink would not be cool!) and it is fabulous. Extra moist, and with a beautuful texture, even at high altitude! Thanks so much for sharing.

Mercedes Said:

Hi Silvana! Can I use any confectioners’ sugar or should it be certified as gluten-free as well? I’m making this cake for a friend’s birthday and I don’t want to mess it up! Or make her sick! Also, I have a gluten free cake mix, should I still use the baking powder and baking soda? The mix already has some. Thanks a lot,

Mercedes from Buenos Aires, Argentina

Mary Ann Fotchuk Said:

I am looking for a gluten free and dairy free birthday cake recipe.. need a frosting recipe too.


Mary Ann

kathy Said:

Amazing cake, made it for my sons birthday, Oh my goodness, what a treat! The perfect time to indulge. Reminded me of a buttermilk cake from long ago, when I use to eat wheat. My son was thrilled. I used cream cheese frosting. He was requesting I make it every week, he is 13. We agreed I would make it again, for the end of the school year. Most our treats are low in sugar and no dairy, however, this was perfect for an day of indulgence and celebration for our son.
THank you again.

Bridy Said:

I have never made anything of yours I didn’t like. I bought your book the instant it came out and I am loving all the new recipes on your blog. Thank you for a super yummy cake! this makes really good cupcakes too. Now I can make a GF cake for all my family birthdays, the kids will love it and I can finally eat a yummy cake to celebrate their day.

stephannie Said:

I just made it, used orange extract and orange peel instead. Natural yogurt and milk and only 2 eggs+2 eggwhites and it was amazingly delicious. Thanks!

Leave a Reply


Get my weekly newsletter
for exclusive recipes, tips
and giveaways...It's FREE!


  • I tastetested dozens of dairyfree ice creams from around thehellip
    2 days ago by silvananardone I taste-tested dozens of ‪#‎dairyfree‬ ice creams from around the nation for  @foodnetwork 's Healthy Eats column...Here are my top 6 picks for the best, the creamiest dairy-free ice cream America’s churning out today! Pictured above is Mr. Dewie's Salted Pecan...yum!! Link in profile...
  • Whats for dessert this weekend? How about my GlutenFree Strawberryhellip
    2 weeks ago by silvananardone What's for dessert this weekend? How about my Gluten-Free Strawberry Shortcake on the  @foodnetwork 's​ blog? They're super flaky and oh, those  #local  sweet strawberries!  #glutenfree   #dairyfreeoptional  (use store-bought coconut Greek yogurt or make your own with the recipe in my new cookbook!) Get the recipe>> link in profile!
  • This is my idea of summer grilling garlicstuffed rosemary baconwrappedhellip
    2 weeks ago by silvananardone This is my idea of summer grilling: garlic-stuffed rosemary bacon-wrapped pork tenderloin and grilled burst local cherry tomatoes and basil.  #summer   #grill   #glutenfree   #dairyfree   #paleo 
  • Fun in the summer sun!
    3 weeks ago by silvananardone Fun in the summer sun!
  • This is chocolate heaven for my girl Brooklyn
    3 weeks ago by silvananardone This is chocolate heaven for my girl...  #Brooklyn 
  • Spicing up my Monday morning with these MushroomCashew Taco Saladhellip
    3 weeks ago by silvananardone Spicing up my Monday morning with these Mushroom-Cashew Taco Salad Bites!  #glutenfree   #dairyfree   #healthy   #vegan 
  • Heres where that chunky guac ended upin my Grilled Shrimphellip
    4 weeks ago by silvananardone Here's where that chunky guac ended up--in my Grilled Shrimp and Chunky Summer Guacamole with Cocktail Sauce good! Recipe coming soon to the  @foodnetwork !  #glutenfree   #dairyfree   #grilling 
  • Chunky summer guac with peaches tomatoes corn red onion limehellip
    4 weeks ago by silvananardone Chunky summer guac with peaches, tomatoes, corn, red onion, lime and of course, avocados!  #local   #summer 
  • The start of something summery and sweet begins with homemadehellip
    4 weeks ago by silvananardone The start of something summery and sweet begins with homemade blueberry sauce.  #nofilter   #summer   #local 
  • Cant wait to dig my spoon into these dairyfree icehellip
    4 weeks ago by silvananardone Can't wait to dig my spoon into these  #dairyfree  ice creams from  @nadamoo  for my next Taste Test for the  @foodnetwork ! Now, which flavor to try first??!!
  • Long Island summer bounty A girl could get used tohellip
    1 month ago by silvananardone Long Island summer bounty. A girl could get used to this.  #local   #farm   #nofilter 
  • Living the Long Island life
    1 month ago by silvananardone Living the Long Island life...
  • NEW recipe for the FoodNetwork! Check out my perfectforsummer piesNoBakehellip
    1 month ago by silvananardone NEW recipe for the  @FoodNetwork ! Check out my perfect-for-summer pies—No-Bake Fruit Pie Minis! I've traded in the average cookie crust for a healthy, nut-based pie shell and filled them with DIY Foolproof Lemon Curd—all ‪#‎glutenfree‬, ‪#‎grainfree‬, ‪#‎dairyfree  #refinedsugarfree ‬ and ‪#‎paleo‬! Click on the link in my profile for more of my pie filling ideas!
  • Freedom! nofilter iluvnyc
    2 months ago by silvananardone Freedom!  #nofilter   #iluvnyc 
  • My Graduate! amotherslove
    2 months ago by silvananardone My Graduate!  #amotherslove 
  • Ive been awake since 4AM trying to figure out howhellip
    2 months ago by silvananardone I've been awake since 4AM trying to figure out how it's already time for Isaiah's high school graduation. There will be a lot of happy tears today!  #cookingforisaiah   #amotherslove 
  • Cooking for Isaiah is have a big moving sale! Tohellip
    2 months ago by silvananardone Cooking for Isaiah™ is have a big moving sale! To celebrate, buy one bag of  #glutenfree   #dairyfree  multi-purpose flour, pancake or bread mix and get one bag for 50% off! Enter promo code: MOVINGDAY (2 bag maximum per order; while supplies last)! Link in profile...  #cookingforisaiah 
  • Kidding around in WilliamsburgHappy Fathers Day!!
    2 months ago by silvananardone Kidding around in Williamsburg...Happy Father's Day!!
  • All in a days work strawberry shortcake assembly! glutenfree dairyfreehellip
    2 months ago by silvananardone All in a day's work: strawberry shortcake assembly!  #glutenfree   #dairyfree   #summer   #nofilter 
  • As Isaiah gets ready to graduate high school in ahellip
    3 months ago by silvananardone As Isaiah gets ready to graduate high school in a couple weeks and go off to college, I find myself flipping through photographs that feel like they were just captured days ago. Soar, my son, soar!  #TBT   #cookingforisaiah   #brooklyn